Tomato Sauce Reviews

Need some more convincing before giving our jarred pasta sauce a try? Read what our extremely satisfied customers have to say about Jar Goods' premium tomato sauce and indulgent vodka sauce.

How about "Exceptional quality and taste!" "BEST SAUCE EVER!!" "Best pasta sauce you can purchase in a jar" "I'm so glad I discovered Jar Goods! The flavor and texture are amazing, and I love that it's made with real, fresh ingredients. Not only does it make the perfect addition to any Italian dish, but it's also great for dipping!" "Jar Goods tomato sauce is the best! The flavors are bold and delicious and it's perfect for any pasta dish." "Jar Goods is hands down the best jarred pasta sauce I've ever had. It's full of flavor and has a great texture!"



Based on 125 reviews
Best Sauce Ever

I love the Classic Spicy Tomato Sauce! It is a delicious combination of spicy tomato sauce and a great way to have a jar that serves two without a huge amount leftover in the fridge forever.

Red Sauce

The sauce was just I remembered from Jule's! Absolutely delicious!


This is a great product and the people are a pleasure to deal with. The package arrived swiftly and in perfect condition.

Best tomato sauce in the market!!

This tomato sauce tastes like slow cooked ripe tomatoes - not sweet, and with the right amount of acidity and spiciness. Since discovering it I don’t use any other.


Wonderful flavor, just like nana used to make, only problem I can,t afford shipping. Wish you were in stores

SUCH a fresh taste!

I'm not typically one to buy jarred tomato sauce, but I was completely blown away by the taste and the freshness of this sauce when I first tried it! This will truly be the only tomato sauce I purchase from here on out!

Delicious Vodka sauce!!

My whole family and I loveee the taste of the classic vodka sauce! We used it to while making homemade coal fire oven pizza and it was the perfect edition to make a something delicious and unique!

Review comments

Jar Goods is a delicious homemade sauce in a jar. It is simple in ingredients and worth the price in taste, and convenience, because it tastes homemade. The varieties make it easier to use the sauces in most any recipe without all the preparation and fuss.

Classic Spicy Sauce Review

Our house likes everything spicy so we're constantly adding hot spices, hot peppers and hot sauces to all our meals. We were very pleasantly surprised by Jar Goods Classic Spicy sauce because it was perfectly spiced and we did not need to add anything. The flavor is amazing and totally satisfied our never ending desire to add a spicy twist to all of our sauce inspired dishes.
Thank you

You can taste the fresh ingredients

When you think about ordering sauce I want to consider the quality and the price. I think that the jars are priced just right and even more so for the quality of the sauce. Similar sauce (especially store-brought) are watery and diluted. Jar Goods has a great flavor that tastes fresh and the sauce is substantially more thick and hearty. I tried some of the meal ideas on the website just to experiment and they also worked well. Overall, I'd say I had a great experience as a first time buyer.

The best jar pasta sauce!

This sauce taste like you are at a great Italian Restaurant! Jar sauce never tastes fresh and like it was home made BUT this sauce does!! My family and friends love it! Order 6 jars at a time!

Missing Jules

Excellent sauce

Just Like Mom Used to Make!

John's Classic Red has a deep, rich tomato taste without acidity nor too much garlic. The ingredients blend together nicely, as well as the hint of sweetness.

Build Your Own Box
rebecca j.

We use Jar Goods exclusively and sharing the product with our friends divulges the secret of our recipes.

Build Your Own Box
Jacquelyn M.B.
Best sauce ever!

The plain red is absolutely delicious. My mom even loves it and it's a perfect size serving ! Recommend!!!

Build Your Own Box
Rachel W.
Not kosher anymore :(

Your tomato sauce was my absolute favorite and I’m so sad it’s not kosher anymore! Ordered it without realizing the certification was gone.


Better than I could ever make myself - in that case, way BETTER than homemade.

Tomato Sauce Box Set

Classic Red Review

We really enjoyed the classic red jar sauce so far. With minimal ingredients, It still tastes very much like slow cooked homemade sauce rather than the mass produced brand types. We can't wait to try the classic spicy jar sauce but we're definitely planning to order classic red to always keep it in stock as our go to specialty sauce.


Great and tasty sauce!

Classic Red

The Best! Received our perfectly packed order and will certainly order more, varieties as well, in the future.
Thank you Ladies ❤️

classic red tomato sauce

My favorite. I don’t have to add anything, It is delicious as is

Simply Fresh & Delicious Sauce

Jar Goods sauce is simply the best tasting tomato sauce. Homemade taste and consistancy.

delicious jar sauce

The taste, texture and consistency of this sauce are very satisfying. It is my go to spicy sauce.

Best sauce ever!