Tomato Sauce Reviews

Need some more convincing before giving our jarred tomato sauce a try? Read what our extremely satisfied customers have to say about Jar Goods' premium tomato sauce. How about "Exceptional quality and taste!" "BEST SAUCE EVER!!" or "Best Sauce you can purchase in a jar."



Based on 114 reviews
Missing Jules

Excellent sauce

Just Like Mom Used to Make!

John's Classic Red has a deep, rich tomato taste without acidity nor too much garlic. The ingredients blend together nicely, as well as the hint of sweetness.

Build Your Own Box
rebecca j.

We use Jar Goods exclusively and sharing the product with our friends divulges the secret of our recipes.

Build Your Own Box
Jacquelyn M.B.
Best sauce ever!

The plain red is absolutely delicious. My mom even loves it and it's a perfect size serving ! Recommend!!!

Build Your Own Box
Rachel W.
Not kosher anymore :(

Your tomato sauce was my absolute favorite and I’m so sad it’s not kosher anymore! Ordered it without realizing the certification was gone.


Better than I could ever make myself - in that case, way BETTER than homemade.

Tomato Sauce Box Set

Classic Red Review

We really enjoyed the classic red jar sauce so far. With minimal ingredients, It still tastes very much like slow cooked homemade sauce rather than the mass produced brand types. We can't wait to try the classic spicy jar sauce but we're definitely planning to order classic red to always keep it in stock as our go to specialty sauce.


Great and tasty sauce!

Classic Red

The Best! Received our perfectly packed order and will certainly order more, varieties as well, in the future.
Thank you Ladies ❤️

classic red tomato sauce

My favorite. I don’t have to add anything, It is delicious as is

Simply Fresh & Delicious Sauce

Jar Goods sauce is simply the best tasting tomato sauce. Homemade taste and consistancy.

delicious jar sauce

The taste, texture and consistency of this sauce are very satisfying. It is my go to spicy sauce.

Best sauce ever!

All the varieties are great

All varieties are great!

Classic Red Tomato Sauce

The only prepared sauce I have ever liked.
Great flavor, perfect consistency, Pairs well with any type of pasta recipes. Excellent for preparing a quick, last minute dinner…

Build Your Own Box
Colleen B.

It is very hard to find sauce with no added sugar that also tastes good and this is it! Delicious!!

Love the sauce - a favorite for the kids


I have been looking for a good vodka sauce, and I’m very particular about it. I finally found it. I LOVE it!

Great Sauce!

I love this spicy sauce and always keep a few jars on hand. When I serve it for guests, they always take a photo of the jar so that they can order some too.
Jeri G.

Classic Red Tomato Sauce - 2 Pack
Felicia M.

Classic Red Tomato Sauce - 2 Pack

So tasty!

My go to jar of sauce. I love the classic spicy version. As someone with severe food allergies, it's not always easy to find premade foods that I can eat. So I really appreciate that this brand uses high quality and minimal ingredients to make a super yummy sauce that I can just keep on hand. Delicious to throw in with a lasagna or chicken parm. Great with pasta and so many other things.
Customer service is fantastic. Order arrived with all sauces intact and very timely.
Keep up the great sauce.

Build Your Own Box
Elizabeth W.
Best Sauce In Town

Love the Original Red. Love love the Vodka Sauce. Love love LOVE the Spicy Sauce! The Jar Goods six-pack came well packed, in a timely manner, and is worth every penny. I can only say this because my ancestors are not here to scold me... but this is better gravy (sauce) than the most skilled Nonna can make! Absolutely delicious! Initially purchased as Jar Goods is a Woman-Owned Business. Will be a regular customer because it's just simply delicious!


The most amazing sauce, the only one I ever want to use.

Love the Sauce!

The Vegan Vodka sauce was exceptionally good—creamy, rich, with a hint of coconut. The marinara was also delicious. I loved having it delivered to the front door. It’s great to keep a few jars in the pantry. There are so many dishes you can whip up for a quick weeknight dinner.